Tax Avoidance

What are the differences for tax purposes between domiciled and non-domiciled status?

A few months ago we published a case study concerning HMRC enquiring about foreign income. This can happen if you are a foreign national and are now living and working in the UK. An area we didn’t touch on was associated with how HMRC views your domiciliary status. The recent news about Rishi Sunak’s wife has highlighted this is somewhat complex and often misunderstood area of tax law. In this short post we’d like to help explain what it means to be ‘domiciled’ or ‘non-domiciled’ where tax in the UK is concerned.

What does ‘domicile’ mean?

In a nutshell, ‘domicile’ refers to that country a person treats as their main or permanent home. Also, it concerns where they actually live and maintain a ‘substantial’ connection with.

If you read our article on “Living Overseas - Do I Need Top Pay Tax if I Leave The UK?”, then you’ll be familiar with the tests that HMRC apply to decide how to treat your current tax residency status. As part of the Automatic UK Test, HMRC looks at your sufficient ties to the UK and whether they point to whether or not you’ve actually left the UK or still have reasons to come back, perhaps regularly. These tests help HMRC determine if you are legitimately living overseas for tax purposes or if perhaps you’re trying to avoid paying UK taxes by staying out of the country for 183 days a year.

Domicile of origin and domicile of choice.

Where UK tax law is concerned, there are three types of domicile - domicile of origin, domicile of choice and domicile of dependence. In the UK, you acquire domicile or origin at birth through your father, although this doesn’t mean the country the person was born in, but most often does. So, if your father is from India, India is your domicile, unless you choose otherwise.

Domicile is different to residency. In UK common law, every individual has one domicile, you can’t have two or have no domicile.

Your domicile of origin cannot be lost easily. Simply by moving overseas for an extended period, becoming a tax resident here or elsewhere, does not automatically remove for domicile status.

However, domicile of choice is a little harder to consider. Take for instance, a UK national. If they move abroad ‘permanently’ to settle in another country. Permanent means ‘indefinitely as it is really up to the person concerned, as is domicile of choice. It comes down to intention’s: if the new country will be their permanent residence, will they have family interests there, a business or other social interests. Do they own a property in that country? And, what about the existence of a Will and where that was created.

It’s quite a tricky area, as there are many variables and many ways to interpret somebody’s intentions. Hence, arguments with HMRC can arise and as always, you’ll need to prove your ‘innocence’ in the matter.

Domicile of dependence is for children under the age of 16 and their domicile will follow that of the person on whom they are legally dependent. However, it must be noted that if the domicile of the parent or legal guardian changes, the child will automatically acquire the same domicile and the child’s domicile of origin will be displaced.

[Read more about what happens if HMRC make enquires about you overseas income]

Important tax issues to consider

It is quite understandable why somebody would not wish to give up their domiciliary, as there may be intentions to return home, the UK being transitory, even though it may appear as somebody’s permanent home.

Take for instance somebody from India who has been living and working in the UK for many years. Their family may still predominantly be in India. They may’ve family business interests there too, or even own property there. In short, there may still be clear intent to return one day.

This means that although a foreign national living and working in the UK maybe a ‘tax resident’ and pay taxes on the income generated through their work here, their ‘non-domicile’ status will mean that their worldwide income does not have to be reported in the UK, as that will no doubt be payable to the tax authorities in the domiciled country. This highlights two options for non-domicile tax residents - being taxed on an arising or remittance basis

Taxed on an ‘arising’ or ‘remittance’ basis

If you are ordinarily considered as UK domiciled and a tax resident, then you are charged on an arising basis. This means that you pay tax on your worldwide income and you’re allowed to use your personal tax allowances and any annual exemptions to offset that income.

However, things are little different and often highly beneficial if you are considered ‘non-domiciled’ while a tax resident in the UK. In this case, you can choose to be taxed on a remittance basis, if that treatment is more favourable than the arising basis. By choosing the remittance basis, you’ll only be taxed on UK sourced income, not worldwide income, unless you decide to ‘remit’ that income. For instance, if you’re a Singapore domiciled national living and working in the UK as a tax resident and a retirement or an assurance policy matures yielding a gain. If you leave the gain in Singapore, no tax is due. If you bring that money into the UK - remit it, then tax falls due.

It’s important to note though that if you choose the remittance basis, you’ll lose your tax allowances and exemptions.

Other factors to consider when using the remittance basis

Do I need to claim to use the remittance basis?

Not necessarily. If your ‘unremitted’ foreign income and gains for the tax year are less than £2000, the remittance basis applies automatically, so you don’t need to claim. Also, it should be noted that at this level, you won’t lose your personal allowance or capital gains annual exemption either. This also allies, even if you are considered ‘domiciled’ for UK tax purposes.

If I choose to remit my income, how will it be taxed?

If you decide to bring some of the income you have earned overseas into the UK, that income will be taxed at the standard (non-savings) tax rates - 20% for basic rate earners, 40% for higher rate payers and 45% for the top tier incomes over £150,000.

Note though that dividend income, where you’d normally see these taxed at 8.75%, 33.75% and 39.35%, will be taxed as ordinary income - which would not be the case if you’d decided to opt for the ‘arising’ basis as opposed to ‘remittance’ basis.

How does the remittance basis work if I am a long term resident?

As the saying goes - “there’s no such thing as a free lunch”. At some point, HMRC will see your long term residency in the UK as a way of reducing your tax exposure and will look to make you pay for that entitlement. So, two bands of charges apply:

Resident for 7 out of the previous 9 tax years. For the privilege of maintaining your remittance basis, you’ll need to pay £30,000 per year.

Resident for 12 out of the previous 14 tax years. For the privilege of maintaining your remittance basis, you’ll need to pay £60,000 per year.

This is HMRC’s way of encouraging people to convert to the ‘arising' basis.

When am I automatically considered domiciled in the UK?

If you have been resident in the UK for 15 out of the previous 20 years, you are deemed as domiciled for tax purposes.

Domiciliary status for tax purposes is a complicated area, seek help

We have presented in rather simple terms the most commonly encountered tax aspects of being domiciled or non-domiciled in the UK. This subject is very complicated as the range of income sources can be extensive as can your ties to the UK if you are non-domiciled. Inheritance tax is another area affected by domiciled status that we haven’t covered here. Rules covering IHT and domiciled status changed in 2017.

If you are encountering issues with taxation as applied to domicile status, it’s likely that you require specialist tax assistance. We're based in London and our offices are conveniently located in Richmond-Upon-Thames, Putney and Cavendish Square. Our tax advisers are on-hand to help you navigate these difficult waters and arrive at an outcome best suited to your personal circumstances. Call 020 8108 0090 or use connect using the form here.

by Robin Brown

Living Overseas - Do I need to pay tax if I leave the UK?

On the face of it, this seems like a simple question and is indeed one many people ask. For some it’s because they are genuinely emigrating to another country, for others, they plan on being away for extended periods of time, perhaps because they are ‘snow birds’, choosing to winter in warmer climes. And then, there are others that look to understand how they can reduce their tax burden because they move around, such as ‘digital nomads’. The reality is though, it’s not that simple.

A common question from UK tax payers spending time overseas in different countries, sometimes for relatively short periods is: “Do I still need to pay tax and if so, to whom?” The answer is “most likely and to somebody”. It all depends on where you are, where you’re considered a tax resident and how much time you have spent there. A common mistake is in interpreting what is known as the 183 day rule. We’ll explore that and other points to consider in this article.

Necessity is the mother of invention

Over the past few years, much about everyday life has changed, especially where work and travel is concerned. Some people have been forced out of necessity to make changes, others driven more by lifestyle changes. Taxation is on the rise in the UK and likely so in many parts of Europe. It’s only natural then, for people prepared to move overseas to think about where they will get the best value for money, where their assets may be taxed less and the impact of tax on their retirement plans. Resourceful savers will seek out the best overseas locations with attractive taxation regimes and likely move.

As people retire, some consider the option of retiring abroad. While in the past, as part of the EU, retiring to the warmer climates of Spain and Portugal was high on the list for British people, Brexit and other restrictions have made for an uncertain future resulting in more than a few people returning to the UK, potentially complicating their tax affairs. Still though, consider plans further afield, such as South East Asia or even Central America. A number of countries offer attractive expat or retirement opportunities for those who can afford the residency and immigration fees.

The key question though remains - what will be my UK tax liability and how do i figure this out?

Enter the Digital Nomad

Even before recent pandemic issues, a new breed of worker emerged - the digital nomad. Digital nomads vary greatly in demographic; some are young adventurous travellers seeking to combine work and the joy or travelling, or even just to be based in a different country for an extended period. Others maybe more mature in years, seeking to leverage overseas property or even rent for an extended period to afford a new work location, or perhaps to avoid the inclement weather in the UK.

A number of countries offer attractive digital nomad packages - often for up to 12 months. For these adventurous individuals, it’s natural to ask the question about tax or indeed if they are able to reduce their tax burden by making such changes to their location and lifestyle, and the specific benefits their own circumstances my lead to in regard to UK tax.

So how do you figure out what tax you owe to whom?

Let’s start by considering when you cease to become a UK Tax Resident.

Many people have heard of the “183 day rule”. Simply applied, this means that if you spend 183 days or more in the UK you become a tax resident and need to pay taxes here. If this is the case for you, then the trail stops here. But what does it mean if you spend less than 183 days in the UK - are you automatically treated as a non-tax resident? This is where mistakes are made and people get caught out. Being out of the UK for more than183 days does not automatically mean you are non-tax resident. To work this out we need to refer to the Statutory Residence Test, from which the 183 day rule emerges.

Introducing the Statutory Residence Test - SRT

Ultimately, whether you are tax resident or not will come down to how you fare when you take the “Statutory Residence Test” or SRT.

There are four main parts to the SRT:

1. How much time you have spent in the UK in a tax year.
2. Automatic Overseas Test.
3. Automatic UK Tests.
4. Sufficient Ties Test.

Part one: How much time you’ve spent in the UK during the tax year 

As we said earlier; if you spend 183 days or more in the UK then you’re a UK tax resident and the test stops here. However, the problem people experience is more evident if the 183 day rule is stated another way: If you’re in the UK for less than 183 days, then you’re not a tax resident. It comes down to how you count, why you’re actually in the UK and what you are up to.

On the face of it, the 183 day rule seems easy to comprehend. In practice though, how HMRC calculates the number of days is not so simple. Let’s start with what HMRC consider as a day? Generally, HMRC considers you as having spent a day in the UK if you were in the UK from Midnight onwards. But, as you’ve probably guessed, other factors apply. In fact, three other considerations need to be made:

1. The ‘deeming rule.
2. Transiting the UK - transit days.
3. Exceptional circumstances.

The deeming rule

As one might reasonably expect, not everyone may spend a full day in the UK if they are not permanently based here. They may be here for meetings or to visit a relative. Perhaps not too surprisingly, HMRC needs to be sure that people are not trying to avoid tax by being based outside of the UK and coming in on a regular basis for part of a day - always a possibility if somebody is based in a close neighbouring EU country or other tax haven.

The deeming rule assesses the following conditions:

1. Whether you have been a resident in the UK for 1 or more years in the past 3 tax years.
2. Whether during the tax year under consideration, you had more than 3 ties to the UK. These include: A family tie, an accommodation tie, a work tie or a 90 day tie. See Ties Test.
3. Whether you were present in the UK on more than 30 days without being present at the end of the day (qualifying day) in the tax year of interest.

More on the deeming rule can be found here.

What’s the impact of the deeming rule?

It basically means that if you meet all the deeming rule’s conditions, after the first 30 qualifying days, all subsequent days within the tax year are treated as days spent in the UK. HMRC gives examples as to how this applies, but in summary, it means that although it may appear that under the SRT you are a non-resident for tax purposes, because of your ties here and previous tax status in the UK, even though you spend less than 183 days here, you may still be treated as a tax resident.

This is quite a complicated consideration and so it is best that you consult with a TaxAgility expert on this issue.

Note: You should still check your tax liabilities with the country you have spent time with though, as their rules may be different and you may still owe tax there. Also check out whether they have a dual taxation agreement with the UK, as this means that any tax you have to pay overseas may be eligible for a tax credit in the UK, lessening your tax liability here.

Transit days

A transit day is a day where you travel to and from other countries via the UK. These are usually not considered full days under the SRT. However, care must be taken here as it may appear tempting to use a transit day as an opportunity to conduct business in the UK or see friends and family. HMRC is quite clear that any activity that is ‘to a substantial extent unrelated to your passage through the UK’, means the day concerned can be counted as a qualifying day. Simply meeting your boss for breakfast or going out on the evening of your arrival with friends, could turn a non-qualifying day into a qualifying day and count towards your allowance. If in doubt, talk to us.

Exceptional circumstances

Sometimes people are forced to return to this country, perhaps because of a death in the family or a sick parent. HMRC are not blind to this and you may be granted special conditions in regard to the total number of days you can spend in the UK.

This may be affected by the number of days you have already spent in the UK, how much work you have engaged in, the location and the type of work involved. Be sure to get clarification on this first though.

Part 2: The Automatic Overseas Test

There are three parts to this test.

First Test: You will be considered as non-resident if you spent fewer than 16 days in the UK during the tax year and were resident in the UK for one or more of the 3 tax years before the current tax year.

Second test: If you were not resident in the UK in any of the three prior tax years and spend less than 46 days in the UK in the tax year of interest, you will be considered as non-resident.

Third test: If you worked overseas full-time over the tax year concerned and:

• spent less than 91 days in the UK in that tax year.
• spent less than 31 days where you worked for more than 3 hours a day in the UK.
• there was no significant break in your overseas work.

A significant break is considered where at least 31 days go by where you’ve worked for more than 3 hours overseas, or would have worked for more than three hours but didn’t because of annual leave, sick leave or parenting leave.

Part 3: The Automatic UK Test

There are three parts to this test.

First automatic UK test: If you’ve spent 183 days or more in the UK, you are a tax resident.

Second automatic UK test: If, for the tax year, you’ve had a home in the UK for all or part of that year and if all the following apply, you’ll be a tax resident:

• one period of 91 consecutive days where you had a home in the UK.
• at least 30 of these 91 days fall in the tax year when you have a home in the UK and you’ve been present in that home for at least 30 days at any time during the year.
• at that time you had no overseas home, or if you had an overseas home, you were present in it for fewer than 30 days in the tax year.
• if you have more than one home, each home should be considered separately for the test and meet the test for one of them.

Third automatic test: You’ll be a tax resident if all the following apply:

• you work full-time in the UK for any period of 365 days, which falls in the tax year.
• more than 75% of the total number of days in the 365 day period when you do more than 3 hours work are days when you do more than 3 hours work in the UK.
• at least one day which has to be both in the 365 day period and the tax year is a day on which you do more than 3 hours work in the UK.

Sufficiency ties test

If you are still in doubt and do not appear to meet the automatic overseas test or the automatic Uk test, then you’ll have to look at your ties to the UK. This will help determine if your time in the UK along with the ties you have here, will make you a tax resident or not. The ties to consider are:

• a family tie.
• an accommodation tie.
• a work tie.
• a 90 day tie.

Also, if in the prior three years you were a UK resident, you’ll need to consider if you have a country tie too. Essentially, the more ties you have to the UK, the less time you can spend here without becoming a tax resident.You can find out more about this here.

Are you considered domiciled in the UK or non-domiciled?

Domicile is another question that often crops up. This typically applies to foreign nationals living and working in the UK. The answer can have a significant impact on your tax liabilities in the UK.

The exact nature of your domicile can change, but ordinarily it is the country of birth for your farther or mother. While you may be considered a UK resident for tax purposes, your domicile status can impact tax on overseas income and inheritance.  The exact impact on your tax affairs needs to be very carefully considered and planned out with a qualified tax advisor. If you have questions concerning tax and your domicile status, talk to our tax advisors.

In conclusion

Tax residency status has a habit of being misunderstood simply because of the belief in the 183 day rule. For sure, if you’ve been in the UK for longer than 183 days then unless you’re looking to qualify under non-domiciliary conditions, you’re almost certainly a tax resident. However, for most people concerned about their tax residency status, it’s more likely they are counting days under 183 and fall foul of the other conditions that HMRC will test your status against. These could potentially limit your time to 16 days in some cases, particularly if you’re based overseas and coming to the UK fairly often or still have many ties to the UK.

Our advice is, don’t assume. Talk to a qualified tax advisor before you travel and discuss your plans for the tax year.

by Robin Brown